Antifreeze Testing - Jan 2006


This testing was done, first, to evaluate the effects of mixing "old" and "new"

antifreezes observing the effects of temperature change. Tested was a new Prestone 

"all use" mixture versus a (very old) Zerex mixture as well as a 50/50 mixture of

the two. See notes at link below.

Secondly, an electrolysis test was performed on the same mixes to assess what

might happen if there is a voltage potential difference between an automobile

radiator and the engine.  Used (both at a ~50% mixture with faucet water) were:

	Prestone "Extended Life Antifreeze/Coolant

	Zerex "Antifreeze Coolant For Extreme Conditions"

	A 50/50 mix of the Prestone & Zerex products.

	Aluminum strips and pieces, about 0.007 inches thick (building flashing)

In the boil/freeze test, aluminum pieces about an inch square were placed in

the solutions. The solutions were then alternately frozen, returned to room

temperature, then boiled and the cycle repeated for several days. This work

provided little information as none of the mixes showed any degradation either

in terms of metallic corrosion or coagulation. It is worthy of note that the

Zerex solutions would not readily strain through a standard coffee filter while

the pure Prestone mix would.

In the electrolysis test, aluminum strip electrodes were placed in the solutions.

Voltage was applied to the strips from a 12 volt battery. The test was suspended 

after 12 hours for the pure Zerex mixture as significant corrosive damage was noted. 

The Prestone solution testing was stopped after 24 hours as no electrolysis 

activity had been noted (no bubbling at the electrodes).

The electrolysis test for the mixture of Prestone and Zerex had an interesting

result. As with the Zerex only solution, electrolysis activity started in seconds.

Differently, though, it seemed to stop after a few hours and appeared non-existent

at the conclusion of 24 hours. However, there was significant debris build up

on the positive electrode as witnessed in the pictures. There was little apparent

damage to the metal of the electrode, quite different than the pure Zerex

solution test. Clearly the addition of the Prestone mitigated the corrosive

damage.

Result pictures show detail of the electrodes (aluminum strips) and the Zerex

solution following the test and then the residual debris in the three solutions

following straining through a coffee filter after the test.

Similarly, the pictures show the residual from straining the mixtures after 

the boil/freeze testing. Basically, nothing noticable either in terms of debris

or damage to the aluminum pieces.